Learning Innovation Lab
Re-imagining Education Through Innovative Designs for Learning Since 2012
  • Home
  • Innovators and Big Questions
  • Tools
  • IN THE NEWS
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Master Innovator Portal
Picture

 Olson Inspiration                    Home        Learn More        Standards        Inspiration        About the Author


Inspiration

Picture
  • Refer to the "Research" page to find out what action research grew from the inspiration found on this page. You can also access the full content of the research paper on this page.
  • Click on the "Design Process" page to discover how the research was conducted and for what audience.
  • Go to the "Support and Next Steps" page to find out where my current inspiration, and action research will take ABC ME next!

Where did the Inspiration Stem From?

From the moment I became a Kindergarten teacher, and performed my first incoming Kindergarten assessments, it become overwhelmingly apparent to me how many students are entering our classrooms behind before they even begin. It was a daunting realization to come to that on the first day of school (and in Kindergarten, I truly mean on their first day of school) a large majority of my students were stepping foot onto an uphill battle. As an educator the thought of this alarmed and saddened me because my aim has and always will be to ensure an inspirational, and equitable education that will prepare ALL of my students for success. My goal as a Kindergarten teacher became to guarantee my students the promise of reading readiness no matter their entry level through the implementation of daily phonics instruction. I became driven by the potential of how prepared my students could exit my classroom, rather than on how unprepared they were when they entered the classroom. With this motivation in constant mind, I began to tackle with how to deliver such daily phonics instruction in a motivating, engaging, and effective manner in order to meet the phonemic needs of all of my learners. I knew that I wanted my phonics instruction to implement technology and to incorporate the use of multimedia because of the motivating and engaging nature it proved to possess in other areas of my instruction. This need became the foundation for the action research I conducted throughout the duration of the Innovative Learning program. 
Picture

The Inspiration Gains Background and Need:

     Over the past three years, less than half (43.90% in 2017) of California’s Grade 3 students have met or exceeded the English Language Arts/Literacy standards as measured by the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP) (https://www.cde.ca.gov/nr/ne/yr17/yr17rel67a.asp). In consideration of all grades tested (3rd-8th, and 11th), less than half (48.56%) of students in 2017 met or exceeded the English Language Arts/Literacy standards as measured by the CAASPP (12.09% of English Learners, 35.52% of economically disadvantaged students, and 13.86% of students with disabilities met or exceeded the English Language Arts/Literacy standards). This data released in the California Department of Education’s 2017 CAASPP Test Results news release suggests that early literacy skills are an area in California’s educational system that is lacking and in need of significant improvement.
      The school district of this study has adopted the use of the DIBELS Next assessment to measure the acquisition of early literacy skills in elementary students. The district yielded the following results for the beginning Letter Naming Fluency section as measured by the 2017-2018 DIBELS Next assessment: 63% of Kindergarten students were likely to need intensive support, 12% were likely to need strategic support, and 25% were likely to need core support. In addition, 45% of Kindergarten students were likely to need intensive support as measured by the beginning period’s First Sound Fluency section of the 2017-2018 DIBELS Next assessment, 22% were likely to need strategic support, and 33% were likely to need core support. This district-specific data, suggested that over half of the incoming Kindergarten population were in need of intensive support to meet the core benchmark standard in Letter Naming Fluency, and nearly half were also in need of intensive support to meet the core standard in First Sound Fluency in the 2017-2018 school year.
Picture

The Transformation of the Inspiration through Literature Review:

A number of researchers have studied the benefits of computer-based technology and computer-assisted instruction as a means of acquiring early literacy skills, especially in reference to preparing pre-kindergarten students for success in school. ​​
Research in Prekindergarten:

Research in Kindergarten:

Computer-Assisted Instruction:
     Shamir, Yoder, Feehan, and Pocklington (2017) also conducted research about the inclusion of a CAI program in a classroom. In this particular study, the effects of the participation of pre-kindergarten students enrolled in a Head Start program in Florida with a CAI program called Waterford Early Learning were examined. The treatment group for the Waterford Early Reading Program was composed of 653 pre-kindergarten students who used the program for over 900 minutes throughout the school year, whereas the control group was composed of 67 pre-kindergarten students who used the program less than 300 minutes throughout the school year. At the end of the school year and at the conclusion of the study, data showed that those students who used the CAI program scored significantly higher than those students who did not in the following skills, Oral Language Vocabulary, Phonological Awareness, and Print Knowledge. Shamir, Yoder, Feehan, and Pocklington concluded that early literacy skills can be advanced by using CAI in the classroom. One weakness of this study is the difference in the number of students who composed the treatment group (653) and the control group (67). The small number of students in the control group as compared with the much larger number of students in the treatment group may have affected the results.

Computer-Based Technology:
    An additional literature search about the use of computer-based technology in the pre-kindergarten classroom in regards to the promotion of early literacy skills produced the research of McManis, McManis, and Gunnewig (2010). McManis, McManis, and Gunnewig focused on the relationship of the use of an interactive whiteboard on the math and literacy readiness skills of pre-kindergarten students. In the 2009-2010 school year, eight public pre-kindergarten classrooms from three schools in three different school districts, all of which delivered instruction in English to English-speaking low-income students, were selected to participate in this study. The teachers of these selected classrooms had used the interactive whiteboard and inclusive content for a year previous to this research so as to eliminate the presence of a learning curve among the teachers in regards to the program and software. The software implemented focused on strategies and activities about literacy, math, social studies, and science skills. The teachers prioritized the use of their program in favor of math and literacy skills, and used the software for at least one hour per week. All of the activities incorporated both visual and auditory aides, as well as, movement and narration on the screen. In addition, there were many opportunities in the software for students to physically engage with the screen by moving objects. Two literacy skills tests were given as both the pretests and the posttests for the early literacy skills portion of the research. The pre and posttest comparison of the Test of Preschool Literacy Early Learning Index (ELI) indicates a significant increase in the acquisition of early literacy skills. McManis, McManis, and Gunnewig found that children can better acquire the skills required for school readiness when they are instructed using educational technology used to provide meaningful and developmentally appropriate concepts, activities, and strategies.

A Media-Rich Classroom:
     Penuel, Pasnik, Bates, Townsend, Gallagher, Llorente, and Hupert (2009) present the results of a research conducted by the Education Development Center, Inc., and SRI International about the relationship of a media-rich curriculum, characterized by the use of television videos and games, and the development of early literacy skills required for school readiness. In this study, 398 children in 80 classes at 47 different pre-kindergarten centers between the ages of four and five participated. Sixty percent of these students spoke English at home, 31% spoke Spanish at home, and eight percent spoke both Spanish and English at home. The focus skills for this study, were letter naming, letter sounds, as well as, story and print concepts. The participants in this study were shown videos from Sesame Street, Between the Lions, and Super Why! as hooks for interactive and teacher-led classroom activities. These students also interacted with online games that provided additional and targeted instruction on the literacy skills taught in the videos. In a ten week span, teachers were required to show each video segment in the weekly curriculum twice. Teachers followed ten weeks of scripts and activities, which also included an alphabet book, picture books, magnetic letters, clay, and other supplemental resources in addition to the videos and online games. The results of this study show a difference among those students who participated in the online literacy curriculum and those who did not on all of the early literacy skills posttests. Penuel, Pasnik, Bates, Townsend, Gallagher, Llorente, and Hupert report that media-rich curriculum, along with accompanied professional development, 
can be successful in preparing  low-income students for school readiness.
 Computer-Assisted Instruction:
​      Macaruso and Walker (2008) conducted a study about the benefits of a computer-assisted instruction that supplemented a Kindergarten phonics-based reading curriculum. The participants in this study included six Kindergarten classes at two urban elementary schools right outside of Boston, Massachusetts. The Kindergarten students used a CAI program called Lexia for approximately 15-20 minutes two or three times a week. The pretests among the groups showed very similar results in phonological awareness and letter-naming skills as measured by the DIBELS assessment. Posttest scores were produced using the Gates-MacGinitie Reading Test. The mean score of the treatment group (54.2) was more significant than the control group (46.4). In addition, the treatment group received higher mean scores than the control group in oral language concepts (phonological awareness), literacy concepts, letters and letter–sound correspondences, as well as listening comprehension. For low performing students, the effect sizes were strong (1.56 for NCE scores, 1.24 for oral language concepts), and for all of students the effect sizes were moderate (.48 for NCE scores, .53 for oral language concepts) on the Gates-MacGinitie Reading Test. As a result, it was found that students, especially low performers, benefited from supplemental, systematic and structured exercises in regards to phonological awareness and letter-sound relationships. This study used a different pre and post test; the results might have been different with the same pre and post test.

Research in Kindergarten/First Grade:

Computer-Assisted Tutoring:
​      In addition to research about the early literacy skills of pre-kindergarten students, a research study about Kindergarten students who participated in a computer-assisted tutoring program that targeted the acquisition of letter sounds had also been conducted. In this study, DuBois, Volpe, and Hemphill (2014) studied 12 kindergarten and 18 first grade students from an urban school in the Northeastern United States identified by their teachers as in need of letter-sound intervention. These students participated in a Tutoring Buddy program. This program was conducted on a laptop in a one-on-one setting, in which students interacted in a two week process defined by pretreatment, one week of intervention, two weeks of intervention, and a one week follow-up. The p value in this study was equal to .008, and the resultant effect sizes were in the medium range: 0.53 for Letter sound Expression (LSE), 0.59 for Nonsense Word Fluency (NWF), and 0.67 for Letter Sound Fluency (LSF), respectively. DuBois, Volpe, and Hemphill’s results indicated that the treatment group had higher rates of growth across the three dependent measures (LSE, NWF, and LNF), as well as performed better in the follow-up than the control group. These results supported the use of computerized intervention as an effective way to meet the needs of those students who display deficiencies in early literacy skills.

Research in First Grade:

An eBook Software Program:
   Katia Ciampa (2012) conducted a qualitative study of the experiences of Grade 1 students who participated in an eBook software program. In her study, eight Grade 1 students used an eBook software program for over 15 weeks. These students participated in 10 sessions of the eBook program, each of which were 25 minutes long. Three of the eight Grade 1 students who participated in the study were identified as “struggling” and “low-achieving” students by their classroom teachers. The observational data confirmed that the three students who previously displayed off-task and avoidance behaviors during reading times in class showed high levels of engagement and involvement during the reading of eBooks, along with the accompanied multimedia-based literacy activities. According to both student and parent questionnaires, students responded positively to being able to choose their own reading materials and were all actively engaged in the selection process. Overall, the study suggested increased student motivation, especially for those students who had not experienced previous success with reading, in response to the use of multimedia and eBook reading in conjunction with conventional reading.
Picture

Research Conclusions:

     Overall, the research conducted thus far has provided evidence in support of the use of supplemental computer-assisted instruction and tutoring programs as a means of improving the phonological awareness and early literacy skills of both pre-kindergarten and Kindergarten students. In addition, research has also suggested the increase in early literacy skills of pre-kindergarten and Kindergarten students who interact with other technological resources, such as eBooks, videos, online games, as well as interactive whiteboards and accompanied software programs. There is a lack of research about the use of whole-class direct phonics instruction, in which PowerPoint is used as a tool to deliver the multimedia-enhanced content driven by the pacing of the classroom’s district-adopted curriculum. There is also a gap in the present research regarding the incorporation of sight words, and writing (both content and conventions) components within the computer-assisted and other technological programs aimed at improving early literacy skills.
      According to Gardner’s (1983) research regarding Multiple Intelligences, students learn in very different ways, and therefore instruction and assessment should reflect this, and learning should be taught and assessed in many ways as well. The purpose of the multi-media approaches in this study were to embrace Gardner’s eight Multiple Learning Intelligences, thereby meeting the needs of all students’ multiple learning styles. By engaging multiple learning styles through multimedia approaches, the primary goal for this specific research is for the students to become proficient in their ability to identify letters, letter sounds, and blend sounds together to read grade-level words. Ultimately, the aim is for students to be able to transfer the skills of letter and letter-sound identification, segmenting, and blending that they are taught during the direct, systematic phonics instruction to all reading and writing that takes place in and out of the classroom. In order to create and teach a direct and systematic phonics instruction that will best benefit students, I needed to know what phonics and early literacy skills they already knew, as well as, an effective order by which letter, and sounds are introduced as measured by the DIBELS Next program. This would ensure that the lessons would be tailored to meet the students’ needs directly and systematically.

Picture

Visit my blog for further insights about my inspiration, research, and creation process:

Picture
Picture
Research
Picture
Design Process
Picture
Support and Next Steps
© 2024 Original copyright 2012-2014, 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved           
Learning Innovation Lab, Leading Innovation Lab and Teaching Innovation Lab (formerly LearnovationLab & TILTnet) are licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Share Alike 4.0 International License.  Based on a work formerly at learnovationlab.org.